by Tony 

Cloud Computing vs SaaS: What’s the Difference?

0 Comments

Cloud Computing vs SaaS: What’s the Difference?

Cloud computing and software as a service are not separate - they are different models of delivery, but the perceived understanding of the boundaries between cloud infrastructure and software as a service can create a significant amount of risk. Most organizations are confusing the two by using the same vendors for both cloud services and SaaS services, which creates a huge financial burden on the organization, and a significant risk of security breaches and data breaches.

Without clearly defining where the responsibility for the infrastructure ends and the setting the governance model begins for your software development, you can NOT build a secure and scalable software development & delivery model.

The cloud services market is projected to reach a total of $3.3 trillion by the year 2033 and SaaS alone will exceed $1.0 trillion by the year 2030. Therefore, when you buy and deploy any SaaS solution it must go through the same rigorous security auditing, cost analysis, and integration mapping as if you were deploying an in-house application.

This must be treated as critical infrastructure decisions.

Planning Your cloud computing saas Strategy

The responsibility matrix for the customer versus vendor creates a fundamental disconnect in the definition of responsibilities for both the customer and the vendor as it relates to an overall cloud computing saas delivery model.

Who is Responsible for What

With Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS), you're purchasing the basic infrastructure to create and host your applications. With an IaaS offering from Amazon, Microsoft or Google, you will be entering into a contractual relationship with them to pay them for the use of virtual machines, storage, and networking to run your applications.

Through services like AWS EC2, Azure VMs or Google Compute Engine, you receive a blank server, and it is up to your IT team to install the operating system, patch it for security vulnerabilities, configure the database, and write the application. You will be responsible for restoring that server should it go down as a result of an improper operating system upgrade.

Google Compute Engine

With Platform as a Service (PaaS), the operating system level is completely removed from your responsibility. Your development teams, using platforms such as Heroku, Azure App Service, or Google App Engine, only need to write code and manage data; the vendor is responsible for hosting and running the servers.

In contrast, Software as a Service (SaaS) significantly reduces your control over all aspects of the application, as the vendor builds, hosts, secures and updates the application. The only areas that remain within your control are managing user identities, securing the data being entered into the system, and configuring how the application operates internally.

Why SaaS Dominates Cloud Spending

Cloud computing continues to grow at an alarming rate overall, but it is clear that the large majority of cloud spending is used for software subscriptions.

The global cloud market is expected to rise from approximately $943 billion in 2025 to approximately $1.18 trillion, culminating in an expected market size of approximately $3.3 trillion dollars by 2033, increasing by 16% every year. SaaS will account for the largest share of the overall cloud service market in terms of market size, with it projected that SaaS alone will reach around $464 billion in 2025 and reach approximately $1.1 trillion by the early 2030s.

While IaaS has a faster growth rate in percentage terms than SaaS, the overall amount of money spent by companies on SaaS makes it a much larger category of spending. Because of this, business units operate independently of IT for purchasing SaaS products — which is a significant factor in the revenue generated for SaaS vendors and an equally large problem for organizations due to the issues associated with governance over SaaS purchases.

Small Business Needs

When evaluating SaaS solutions, a small business-to-business organization must be mindful of the company's size and business model. This includes considering their tech stack or initial technology offerings. Because their available technical resources are extremely limited, a 30-person startup must prioritize which technologies to use based on the need for simplicity, speed of deployment, and direct integration.

Why SaaS Dominates Cloud Spending

When evaluating a CRM, billing, or support software solution, a small startup cannot afford to invest in software that requires custom coding or development. Therefore, the startup should purchase only those SaaS products that provide the highest level of out-of-the-box integration with the other SaaS products the startup will be using.

Vendors that provide native, one-click integration with a start-up’s existing tools are the most attractive to small teams. Conversely, small teams should also focus on SaaS vendors that will make their lives easier by providing an open-door policy, which means that they can easily obtain assistance from customer support.

Mid-Market Challenges

Mid-market companies, which typically have 300 or more employees at this point, have moved from a focus on speed to a focus on control and consolidation. In many cases, mid-market organizations are also significantly impacted by issues with shadow IT as employees use their personal credit cards to purchase software that is not approved by IT. Therefore, it is critical that IT leaders establish a way to control and enforce policies around decentralized purchasing of SaaS products by employees of mid-market organizations.

To achieve this, IT organizations must have a centralized SaaS management platform that helps track spending and usage for all the SaaS products utilized by an organization.

Furthermore, companies must ensure that all their SaaS products have been configured to require the approval and use of single sign-on (SSO) and multi-factor authentication (MFA). Companies use tools like JumpCloud to help manage user identities across many separate applications.

In this phase of SaaS program development, the objective is to identify applications that duplicate one another, cancel any unused subscriptions, and move all remaining application data into a single, controlled list of accepted software applications.

Enterprise Security and Compliance Standards

In large organizations, software purchases are viewed from three perspectives: risk, compliance, and the provision of audit evidence.

For enterprise security officers developing SaaS programs for their organization, the minor features of the software do not hold any interest; they only care about third-party risk. To mitigate this risk, they need to verify that the vendors have been awarded a SOC 2 Certification, and that they comply with international data residency laws.

Therefore, companies embarking on a cloud computing saas vendor purchase will need to complete multiple security questionnaire reviews, conduct penetration testing for that vendor, and undertake negotiations regarding the Service Level Agreement for that vendor.

Enterprise Security and Compliance Standards

Enterprises also need to provide ongoing access reviews.

Enterprises require 100% visibility into who has administrator rights in all applications. Enterprises must be able to build a configuration model that allows for rapid business agility without violating enterprise security compliance standards.

Sales-Led vs Product-Led Growth

The manner in which a vendor sells their products can significantly affect your evaluation strategy.

In product-led growth (PLG), your employees can sign up for free and begin using the product immediately, with the option of paying with a credit card upon upgrading to a paid version. While PLG models promote rapid adoption of users, they create significant security gaps if there is no oversight of usage. If your business handles sensitive customer data, it is imperative that you restrict improper PLG usage at the network level.

In a sales-led model, if you want to purchase a product from a vendor, you will have a conversation with a company representative, enter into a contract for one year, and complete an onboarding process prior to using the product. Although there is a risk of delayed sales using this path, this option gives your IT and security teams the time required to review the platform, validate data migration, and calculate total cost of ownership before staff ever even touch the system.

Execution and the Implementation Plan

Pre-Implementation Timeline

The first step in deploying a new cloud computing saas platform is to create a calendar and stick with this calendar throughout the project, otherwise the project will fail.

In order to have a successful implementation of a new software platform a pre-implementation schedule will typically last twelve weeks.

The time period of weeks one and two is the timeframe to have leadership define the specific business goals, appoint a single accountable project owner and assemble a cross-functional project team. If you do not assign a single individual as an accountable project owner, the project will be stalled.

The time period of weeks two through four is the period of time that the project team is planning.

This is when the project team creates data migration plans, completes security reviews and develops the integration architecture. The timeframe of weeks four through eight are the actual technical implementation, including tool configuration, user role setup, and sandbox testing. The period of weeks eight through twelve is the time required for official launch, user training, and early stabilization activities.

Pilot Group Design

Do not implement a new software platform into the entire organization at once before you identify a pilot group of five to ten users who will test the new system in "real world" conditions prior to the official rollout.

This pilot group must not only be made up of techie employees or management personnel but should also consist of employees from other functions, especially employees who are generally slow to adopt new technology.

Pilot Group Design

The pilot group will be the first users to experience the many ways that the new system will be broken that your IT team did not foresee. Companies can identify missing fields, broken rules, and confusing elements of an interface during the pilot program. By fixing these things while still in the pilot phase, businesses can avoid failure when rolling out company-wide.

Workflow Complexity and Integration Density

When considering a new piece of software, you should create a mapping of all the systems that must communicate with it. The higher the density of integration, the more expensive it will be to maintain. When reviewing a software application, always check the amount of effort that will be required to create a native connection and/or custom API connection.

Begin by requiring only the 2 or 3 most important integrations.

Do not try to tie all possible systems together on day one. Focus first on the core data flows that produce the fastest return on investment in terms of revenue and time savings. In fact, the top ten workflows in any organization will typically account for between 60% and 70% of the expected automation value. The other integrations should be deferred until the core component of the integration is properly functioning.

Setting Up a Governance Review Cycle

Post-go-live governance is what determines whether or not the project will be financially viable. You need to create mandatory review meetings at 30, 60, and 90 days after going live.

During those reviews, you need to be tracking the following metrics to gauge employee adoption.

Are employees visiting daily? Have they completely phased out their old legacy systems? Are the automated workflows functioning properly without any errors? When it comes to monitoring software usage in your organization, it is critical to intervene early if you see that software has not been adopted by your users after the first 30 days. Waiting until the annual renewal date can result in lost revenue because the software has likely been ignored by your users, and you have not intervened.

The Software Security Mandate

Software security will likely be the most important factor in the purchase of new software. Organizations will look to SaaS providers to fill the security gap that exists in many organizations. Security teams within organizations will also begin to play a larger role in the selection of SaaS providers.

A recent survey has shown that 86% of all organizations place a high priority on the security of SaaS products. In fact, 76% of organizations have either increased security budgets or are planning to do so to provide the additional resources needed to secure SaaS products. The majority of the risk for organizations is no longer coming from external threats (hackers), but rather, the risks associated with employees within the organization.

Over 63% of organizations reported that employees within the geographical area of the organization are sharing confidential data with unauthorized parties.

In addition, 56% of organizations explicitly stated that employees are uploading sensitive corporate data to unauthorized applications. Employees at 55% of organizations begin using software without receiving input from their security team, resulting in fragmented administrative processes for securing proprietary data.

API Access and Identity Risks

To reduce the risk of unauthorized software usage, organizations must restrict network permissions and utilize secure gateway access for all Internet traffic.

API Access and Identity Risks

The current attack surface is primarily created by machines communicating with machines.

When organizations connect two software applications to each other, they create a non-human identity that interacts with the two systems typically via an API key. Currently, 46% of organizations have difficulty monitoring non-human identities, and 56% are very concerned about the over-privileged API access that is granted to these identities.

If an organization grants administrative rights to an API key and then forgets about it, then that key will likely continue to serve as a permanent backdoor into the organization's database.

Organizations are failing to effectively manage the identity lifecycle of employees and contractors, creating a significant risk to their continued security.

More than 58 percent of organizations are having difficulties implementing basic privilege restrictions, while 54 percent do not have the means to automatically remove someone’s access to a system when that person leaves employment or when a software integration ceases to be supported.

Automated Compliance Tools

Manual compliance checks simply don't work in a cloud-first world.

You have to implement a complete set of security tools that can be used to manage your compliance and configuration risk. To automate the audit process and maintain a record of compliance, tools such as Vanta, Drata, and Scrut can be integrated with your systems to provide you continuous evidence to be used during SOC 2 (SOC Type 2) or ISO 27001 audits.

However, tools like these do not address active threat issues.

In order to protect your system from these threats, you must use a posture management engine. Tools like Prowler, Wiz, Orca, and Prisma examine your entire software and cloud environment in real-time to detect configuration errors, wide-open data buckets, and excessive user authorization rights.

The True Cost of cloud computing saas Workflows

The monthly price of a software subscription is a trap.

The TCO of a given SaaS product is made up of the subscription fee, the implementation charge, the amount of effort required to maintain the software, and any costs associated with third-party integrations. Mid-market workflow automation has a median spending level of $3,200 per month.

However, there are some painful initial implementation fees.

For example, most business-to-business (B2B) companies with between $2 million and $40 million in annual recurring revenue (ARR) pay between $1,500 and $8,000 monthly for SaaS but pay between $5,000 and $60,000 as one-time implementation costs. Prior to signing a contract, you must consider budgeting for these substantial upfront implementation fees.

Analyzing ROI for RevOps Tools

In order to facilitate growth with RevOps tools, there is a requirement for companies to invest significantly in them.

The average percentage of spend amongst the top quartile of software companies in this area of spending equal to between 14% to 22% of their overall operating costs, with a significant portion of this as it relates to automation.

Although a smaller company generating $5 million ARR may experience little expense, they will likely still have high levels of expenditures.

Typically, such a company will pay $1,800 to $3,500/month for the core software and incur an additional $8,000 to $20,000 in initial implementation costs. The software must result in a savings of manually completed tasks or must enable the sales cycle to occur faster than nine months to recover from the implementation costs to justify the expense.

Artificial Intelligence in the Next Generation Stack

Evaluating AI Capabilities

When evaluating a software vendor’s generative AI capabilities, you need to carefully assess how these features will affect their products.

Artificial Intelligence in the Next Generation Stack

Today there are no longer just databases that can be purchased; you are purchasing a platform with an artificial intelligence engine that can read your proprietary data and index and process that information. During the evaluation phase, you must pay close attention to how the software utilizes the AI features of the platform.

You will need to differentiate between the value of true operational capability and the risk associated with marketing hype.

You need to ask the vendor how your data will be utilized to train their models. If the vendor states they will have access to internal customer records to train their global AI capabilities, you must decline to enter into a contract immediately.

Managing AI-Driven Integrations

When a vendor like Workato offers the ability to provide complex SaaS-to-SaaS integrations, it is now possible for an AI agent to initiate a series of automated actions across several connected systems on behalf of a user without the need for them to explicitly approve.

If an AI system has excessive permissions and there is a situation where it produces an erroneous or false output (also known as hallucinating), this could trigger a wide-scale automated action such as sending out emails to clients or deleting large numbers of records from your customer relationship management (CRM) system.

Isolating AI in a Sandbox

Ensuring that no AI can ever create a workflow, to write to the financial or customer database, without a human approving it via a hardcoded control will ultimately safeguard the entire company from a catastrophic error.

Common Implementation Failures

Data Migration Errors and Integration Debt

The majority of software implementations fail prior to any of their users logging in.

Data migration is the single largest reason why software implementations fail. Organizations will attempt to transfer numerous years of poorly formatted, disorganized and unstructured legacy data into a brand new system, which will create duplicate records, broken relational linkages, and corrupted reporting capabilities.

Companies should take the necessary steps to clean and format their legacy data prior to starting the process to migrate even one row of data into their new software application.

Integration debt is the second most common reason for software implementation failures. Organizations will frequently create temporary API integrations between two systems so that two incompatible applications continue to connect to each other. Once one of the vendors releases an updated version of their API, the integration ceases to operate correctly. Generally, these issues will continue without any detection until a significant amount of time passes.

Over-Customization and Training Gaps

There is an overwhelming tendency to customize software instead of using the software as is. Companies will spend an excessive amount of time modifying the vendor’s interface, creating excessive numbers of custom fields, and writing elaborate business automation logic in order to make the new tool act like the inefficient process that they used to follow; however, this practice has the reverse effect. By excessively customizing a software application, organizations render new vendor updates impossible.

Companies must adapt their internal processes to fit the features of their new software, as opposed to the prior approach of adapting the features of a new software application to fit their internal processes.

Upon launching a new application, it is likely that when you provide your users with general training video content, the training will not be effective. You must also provide users with role-specific training. Therefore, a sales representative should be shown the exact same three clicks to complete a sale, while a manager should be shown how to pull pipeline reports. General, broad-feature training will not achieve the necessary levels of user adoption.

The Reality of Software Ownership

A software application does not belong to you. You are only responsible for how you implement, secure and deploy the application. Cloud applications should be treated as critical operational infrastructure, rather than casual internet applications.

About the author 

Tony

Tony is a systems architect and cloud infrastructure specialist with a deep focus on product-led growth dynamics. Through his work at SSC, he dissects complex enterprise software integrations, multi-tenant database scaling, and API automation frameworks. His technical guides serve as a benchmark for CTOs and VPs of Engineering aiming to streamline their software product lifecycle.

Ready to Deploy Our Architecture?